Social proof is the habit of looking at what other people did when you are unsure what to do yourself. The psychologist Robert Cialdini listed it among his principles of persuasion, now often called consensus. Someone choosing a service provider they have never met has little to go on. Your website’s job is to show them that people like them already chose you and were glad they did.
Briefly explained
- Following what others did when you are unsure what to do.
- For a service business, mostly reviews, real photos and local names.
- It works best right next to the phone number.
- Fake or bought reviews break FTC rules.
Why does social proof work?
Because choosing a service provider is a risky decision made with little information.
A new customer has usually never used your business before, so they have no way to judge the quality of the work on their own. So they look at what earlier customers said instead. A review from someone nearby answers the question the customer actually has: did this go well for someone like me?
What counts as social proof on a service website?
More than a star rating.
- Reviews and testimonials: The main form, best quoted with a first name and, where the customer agrees, their town or neighborhood.
- Real photos: Your actual work, team and premises, not stock images.
- Local names: Neighborhoods, local organizations or business clients you have worked for, named with their permission.
- Track record: Years in business and professional or industry association memberships.
- Rating and review count: Taken from your Google Business Profile and kept current.
Skip stock photos with invented names under a quote, because they present a customer who does not exist.
Where should it go on the page?
Next to the phone number and the form.
A testimonials page asks the visitor to go looking for reassurance, and few will. Put one piece of proof above the fold, close to the phone number. Put a short review beside the contact or quote form, and a relevant one on each service page, from a customer who bought that service. Proof that matches the service the visitor came for does more than a general rating at the bottom of every page.
How do you get more of it?
Collect it as part of the everyday work.
- Ask for a review after every completed service or visit, at the moment the work is done. See review velocity.
- Photograph the work before and after where you can, and keep the photos where your website can use them.
- Ask permission before quoting a customer by name or showing their photo, home or business.
- Reply to reviews, because the replies are proof too. See review response.
What breaks the rules?
The FTC treats fake reviews and testimonials as deception.
- Fake or bought reviews: Banned under the FTC’s Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule.
- Hiding the negative ones: The FTC’s Endorsement Guides say that showing only the glowing reviews and suppressing the rest can be deceptive.
Some professions, such as healthcare and law, may have their own rules on testimonials and client photos. Check those before publishing any.
State rules can add requirements of their own. If you are unsure about a specific practice, ask a lawyer rather than a marketer.
What do the terms mean?
- Consensus: The name Cialdini’s organization uses for social proof. People follow the lead of many others.
- Testimonial: A customer’s statement you publish, with their permission.
- Trust signal: Any element that reduces doubt, from a license number to a review.
- Review velocity: How steadily new reviews arrive, which keeps the proof current.
Owner questions
